Every Family Has Traditions — Ours Just Happens to Taste Like Prime Rib

Why the Hashknife Ranch Holiday Favorite Deserves a Place at Your Table

Here we are again, the holiday season. From Thanksgiving to the New Year, this is part of the calendar where major gatherings and family get-togethers seem to be endless.

Every family has its own holiday rhythm. Some unwrap presents on Christmas Eve. Some bake the same cookies every year. Some gather around a table full of dishes that only appear once a season — perhaps the ones that smell like childhood and taste like home.

At the Hashknife Ranch, we are no different.

We have our own traditions, our own stories, and our own, personal, holiday favorites.

But if there is one dish that brings everyone, far and wide, to the ranch and the holiday table — our family Prime Rib using Tex Carpenter’s (the Ranch’s fourth generation) lifelong developed recipe.

If you are looking for a holiday centerpiece that delivers comfort, celebration, and a little bit of ranch-raised pride, we happily share ours with you.

 

Why Prime Rib Is the King of Holiday Meals

Prime Rib is not just a roast. It is a moment.

It is the kind of meal that fills the house with a slow-building aroma — buttery, rich, and unmistakably festive.

It is the cut that rewards patience.

Prime Rib is naturally tender, beautifully marbled, and full of flavor.

This is something we usually reserve for Christmas dinner, but we happily serve it at Easter, Thanksgiving, and New Year's Eve as well. This is a great overall dish that can be prepared for any occasion you deem fit.

 

Ranch Beef is NOT Necessary for a Better Prime Rib

Most producers use something like this to pull at your heartstrings and maybe leverage some nostalgia to suggest making your custom beef produce a Prime Rib Roast.

This may come as a shock, but we disagree. Here is why:

We will always recommend that you use your custom beef to maximize your meals. Instead of a roast, ask the butcher for Rib steaks when customizing your order cut.

Instead, we recommend you find the best deal you can for any Rib Roast, regardless of the grade, from a local butcher or anywhere you trust to produce your meat. Usually, this means searching for the most affordable roast you can find during the weeks leading up to Christmas.

Why get a lower grade roast? Because the cut is already naturally marbled and full of fat.

There is no need to find a Prime grade roast when you will end up paying more for weight you ultimately trim off your roast anyway.

 

Why Buy Prime Rib? The answer is always the same:

Prime Rib is special and elevates everything to another level, especially when it is done right. It says, “Welcome, enjoy this labor of love we have happily provided to you this year!”

Here’s why:

  • Superior marbling regardless of the USDA grade

  • Consistent texture

  • Richer flavor from marbling and quality U.S. production

  • Better moisture retention

If done right, your holiday roast is not just good — it is steakhouse-level.

 

The Hashknife Ranch Family Prime Rib Tradition

Every year, when the weather turns cold and the days get short, our family gathers around a roast that has been prepared the same way for three generations now.

It is simple.

It is reliable.

It is the kind of recipe that does not need tweaking because Tex perfected it long ago.

We season it generously. We let it sit with the marinade for at least 24 hours, and longer if we can. We sear it, then roast it slowly. We slice it thick. And we serve it with pure love.

This is the meal that brings the whole crew home. It makes people ask if they can return for another holiday meal the following year.

It is the meal that reminds us why ranching and producing beef is all worth it.

 

Our Recommended Favorite:

The Hashknife Prime Rib Recipe

We believe every family should have a holiday dish that feels like theirs. If you do not yet have one — or if you feel a need to upgrade — this is the one we recommend.

It is straightforward and it showcases the quality of beef, regardless of grade, better than anything else you can put on the table, particularly during special times of the year.

 

 

The Hashknife Ranch Prime Rib Recipe

 

PRIME RIB ROAST

INGREDIENTS NEEDED

(For 20 Lb. roast)

 

Choosing an excellent piece of Prime Rib is critical as to what the taste and tenderness will be.

Note: Ask the butcher to cut the ribs from the meat and use cotton cord to tie the ribs and meat back together for cooking.  When possible, get the large end of the rib rather than a small end.

Make sure to also purchase 3 Lbs. of 1½ inch thick fat jacket chunks (surplus fat from other cuts)

                                                                                

NOTES

When a 10 pound or smaller roast is used, cut the above measures in half.

 

MARINADE

Mix well the dry ingredients: ½ cup salt, ½ cup black pepper, 1/4 cup onion power.

Make a paste of the marinade using water.  Add the water a few drops at a time as too much water will make the paste too wet.  Rub and knead the marinated seasoning into the entire surface of the roast.  The roast should look like it was covered with a thick layer of dirty sand when finished.  Let the roast sit inside refrigerator for at least twenty-four hours.

A small piece of meat would be covered with a very light (use very wet mixture) layer of marinated spice. Too much spice will waste the outside of the smaller roast as it will be too salty to eat and would have to be trimmed off, creating waste.

 

PREPARATION

Liberally place the rub mix on the roast at least 24 hours in advance. Let it sit with the rub to help penetrate flavor into the roast before cooking.

If you want to assist in creating a richer, deeper flavor in the roast, stab the meat all over with a fork to help the marinade settle within the small pockets throughout the cut.

We have done marinades up to one year long by freezing the rubbed roast, and we felt it significantly improved the overall flavor and taste.

 

COOKING DAY

Start cooking the roast according to its size using one hour of cooking time for each four pounds of roast.

Example: A 20-pound roast to be served at 12:00 noon would have to be started at 7:00 a.m. that same morning.  A small roast will cook through and shrink faster so less cooking time and heat per pound should be considered.

 

Preheat the oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit.

Lay the roast with the rib bones down on the 3 lb. layer of fat jacket.  Do not cover.

 

Note: Leave the cotton cord used to tie the ribs and meat back together on while cooking.

 

Sear the roast in the oven for 15 to 30 minutes depending upon size.  Turn the heat down to 300 degrees Fahrenheit.  When the roast has cooked for half of its cooking time, turn over and turn the heat down to 275 degrees Fahrenheit.

 

Check for rareness by using fork test: stab to center of roast with a long-tine cooking fork.  When the center is just warm, this constitutes for rare steaks when sliced.  Using a meat thermometer is optional to target your desired temperature. Cut the cord off to slice 1" or thicker rare steaks.  Slice ½” to ¾” thick steaks that will be made well done by further cooking in very hot au jus. Cut larger steaks in half for more servings or kids.

The middle of the roast will be rarer, and the ends will be more flavorful with the rub but tend to also be drier and spicier. Allocate the servings appropriately to guests based on flavor and doneness.

 

In the immortal words of Tex Carpenter:

“Do not overcook. A rare piece of meat can be salvaged...an overcooked piece of meat is a crime.”

 

  SERVING SUGGESTIONS

  • Use preheated pewter or stainless-steel plates set in wooden serving trays.

  • Gently ladle hot au jus over the steak.

  • Fresh horse radish is a favorite for many in our family.

  • Consider wine sauteed mushrooms as a favorite topping.

  • Roast can be left in roaster with heat off for up to 2 hours.  Reheat and serve.

 

 

A Tradition Worth Passing Down

Whether your family has a long list of holiday favorites or you are building new traditions of your own, Prime Rib is a dish that brings people together.

It is celebratory without being fussy. It is comforting without being ordinary.

From our family at the Hashknife Ranch to yours — we hope this recipe becomes part of your holiday story, just like it is part of ours.

Hashknife Ranch

The official website for Hashknife Ranch Montana!

https://www.hashkniferanchmt.com
Next
Next

Prime vs. Choice: What is the Real Difference?